SEARCH:

search

JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER:

go

Calendar

Bookmark and Share

Thought To Ponder

No nation was ever ruined by trade.
Benjamin Franklin

 The Ten Pillars of Economic Wisdom 
2 December 2004
Fred G Clark and Richard Stanton Rimanoczy

1. Nothing in our material world can come from nowhere, nor can it be free; everything in our economic life has a source, a destination and a cost that must be paid - by someone.

2. Government is never a source of goods. Everything produced is produced by the people, and everything that government gives to the people, it must first take from the people.

3. The only valuable money that government has to spend is that money taxed or borrowed from people's earnings. When government decides to spend more than it has thus received, that extra unearned money is created out of thin air, through the banks and/or the printing presses, and when spent, takes on value only by reducing the value of all other money, savings and insurance.

4. In our modern exchange economy, all payroll and employment come from customers, and the only worthwhile job security is customer security. If there are no customers, there can be no payroll and no jobs.

5. Customer security can be achieved by the worker only when he/she cooperates with management in doing the things that win and hold customers. Job security, therefore, is a partnership problem that can only be solved in a spirit of understanding and cooperation.

6. Because wages are the principle cost of everything, wide spread wage increases without corresponding increases in productivity, simply increase everyone's cost of living.

7. The greatest good for the greatest number means, in its material sense, the most goods for the greatest number, which, in turn, means the greatest productivity per worker.

8. All productivity is based on three factors: (a) natural resources, whose form, place and condition are changed by the expenditure of (b) human energy (both muscular and mental), with the aid of (c) tools.

9. Tools are the only one of these three factors that man can increase without limit, and tools come into being in a free society only when there is a reward for that portion of their earnings that people must temporarily channel into new tools of production as opposed to purchases that produce immediate comfort and pleasure. Proper payment for the use of tools is essential for their creation.

10. The productivity of the tools-that is, the efficiency of the human energy applied in connection with their use-has always been highest in a competitive society in which the economic decisions are freely made by millions of progressive-seeking individuals, rather than in a state-planned society in which those decisions are made by a handful of all-powerful people, regardless of how benevolent, sincere and intelligent those people may be.

We had previously published the Ten Pillars of Economic Wisdom and attributed it to "Anonymous". However the following information was provided from a reader in California today, Wednesday, July 26, 2006.

Fred G Clark and Richard Stanton Rimanoczy (Chairman and President of The American Economics Foundation, 51 East 42 St., NY, NY 10017-as of 1969, the date of my book, "How We Live", where their Ten Pillars appeared). D Van Nostrand held the copyright. The Pillars apparently were on 10 plaques in the Hall of Free Enterprise at the 1964 NY City World's Fair.

We sincerely appreciate this information so our record is correct.

Help support The Nassau Institute

Comments

Joan - 20 October 2010 09:25
Ten Pillars
Ken, No one is obliged to work for "idiot" employers and "decision-making power" is seldom the preserve of any individual - except political dictators.
Each of the ten "pillars" are symbols for universal principles - but as in life there are imperfections - usually as a result of interpretation and/or perception.
Ken - 20 October 2010 02:20
ok
1-4 are essentially true. 5 falls on it face when employers are idiots but hold all the decision making power.A fervent realityin The Bahamas. 6 may not always be true, that is raw material and production could surpass labour costs.9 seems to ignore technology and the econo-technical history of the last 50 years. The majority must always be and feel that they are participants or the enterprise will fail. This is also true where special interests actually control the decisions made by a few.
Bego Gerber - 18 November 2009 12:44
The Ten Pillars of Economic Wisdom
Here is the citation for the 1964 World's Fair source of these pillars: http://www.worldsfairphotos.com/nywf64/booklets/hall-of-free-enterprise-groundbreaking-5-8-63.pdf. It would improve your credibility to change your attribution ("Fred G Clark and Richard Stanton Rimanoczy (Chairman and President of The American Economics Foundation, 51 East 42 St., NY, NY 10017-as of 1969, the date of my book, "How We Live", where their Ten Pillars appeared). D Van Nostrand held the copyright. The Pillars apparently were on 10 plaques in the Hall of Free Enterprise at the 1964 NY City World's Fair.") accordingly.

Of course, just because there's a consensus about these does not mean that they are correct. For instance, the last sentence of #9 is belied by the thriving world of open source and free software often created purely pro bono publico and without thought of remuneration.

In another instance, Pillar #6 is simplistic, even naive, in using the word "simply". While it may be true on the average, the reality is very complex and chaotic such that local benefits or detriments may occur as a consequence of local or remote changes in wages or productivity, and these may or may not be beneficial at the time. Moreover, increasing productivity does not always lead to increased wages, depending on the benevolence of the owners and management; hence the pressure among workers for collective bargaining.

Beware your dogma does not get run over by your karma.

Peace,

Bego Gerber

Add new comment:
Name *
E-mail  
Subject *
Comment *
number
In order to prevent "spam entries", we require that you enter the numerical code in the grey box, as you submit your posting. Thank you for your cooperation.
You may edit it as long as you don't exit your browser. After moderator approval, it will be visible for public.